TaxAble

experts in tax

  • Business Tax
    • Type of business taxes
      • Income tax
        • Corporate income tax rates 2019
        • Corporate income tax rates 2020
        • Corporate income tax rates 2021
      • Wage tax / premiums
      • Value Added Tax (VAT)
      • Dividend withholding tax
      • More business taxes
    • Tax planning
    • Compliance services
    • Tax calculator
  • Personal Tax
    • Personal income tax rates
      • Personal income tax rates 2021
      • Personal income tax rates 2020
      • Personal income tax rates 2019
    • Type of personal taxes
      • Personal income tax
      • Inheritance and Gift tax
    • Personal income tax return
    • 30% ruling
    • Expat tax
  • One Stop Shop
    • Setting up a Dutch company
    • Tax compliance & Accountancy services
    • Partners & Network
  • News
    • News on Business Tax
    • News on expat tax
    • News on personal tax
    • News on the 30% ruling
    • Other tax news
  • About Us
    • Testimonials
    • Background
    • Associations
    • Terms & Conditions TaxAble
  • Contact
  • Nederlands
  • English
You are here: Home / All Articles / News on personal tax / Proof may not be reversed without invitation letter

Proof may not be reversed without invitation letter

March 5, 2018 by Jan-Hein

This post is also available in: Nederlands (Dutch)

The Dutch tax authorities may not reverse the burden of proof if an invitation to file a personal income tax return (aangiftebrief) has not been sent them first.

Recently, Tax Court issued a judgment in a case in which the tax authorities wanted to reverse the burden of proof after imposing an ex officio estimated income tax assessment.

The taxpayer in this case had not filed a tax return and also had not received an income tax return invitation from the tax authorities. The inspector made an ex officio estimated tax assessment and took the view that the burden of proof was on the taxpayer to refute the amounts of the ex officio tax assessment.

The Court saw sufficient reason to submit the burden of proof – of the estimated amounts of the ex officio assessment – to the tax authorities because the taxpayer did not submit an (incorrect) declaration and had not received an invitation to file a tax return. At least the inspector could not provide evidence that such an invitation had indeed been sent to the taxpayer, although the inspector was convinced that it was.

Incidentally, the inspector in this case still had the chance to successfully defend the height of his ex officio attack so that this estimated tax assessment was maintained.

Perhaps the Tax Authorities will try to prevent a similar future case as much as possible by sending many taxpayers an invitation to file a tax return.

7.9 million people were invited over the tax year 2017, including persons who would not actually have to file a declaration, making the invitation in such cases more like an unauthorized ‘fishing expedition’.

The law hereby imposes the following restriction on the inspector: “Pursuant to Article 6 paragraph 1 AWR, the inspector … can invite the person who, in his opinion, is presumed to be liable to pay tax or is liable to pay deductions.” So there must be a suspicion before an invitation can be send.

In view of the formalities and the impact of such an invitation, it should only be issued in evident situations: “anyone who has been invited to prepare a tax return is required to make a declaration by means of the information requested in the invitation, clearly, firmly and without reservation….”

With or without tax return invitation letter (aangiftebrief) we can be of service to you when drawing up your personal income tax return.

Want to know what we can offer?

Drop us a line

Filed Under: News on personal tax, Other tax news

  • Please type in letters
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent posts

  • Changes in Dutch tax 2024 for companies and individuals
  • Article 23 VAT permit for a cash flow advantage with import
  • Developments in the Excessive Borrowing from your own BV
  • Deposit annual accounts with Dutch Chamber of Commerce
  • Make use of the One Stop Shop to avoid having to register VAT per country

Search

News categories

  • All Articles
    • News on Business Tax
    • News on expat tax
    • News on personal tax
    • News on the 30% ruling
    • Other tax news

Copyright © 2025 TaxAble :: experts in tax

© Taxable 2017 –2025 - Privacy statement

  • Nederlands
  • English